Your Thoughts on Sewing Blogs

Thank you to everyone who read and commented on my last post. It obviously struck a chord and there were many long and wonderfully thought-through comments. I've replied to everyone who has commented so far, and the comments are still coming.

  Crafters' Ceilidh Meet Up in Edinburgh, 2012

There's no doubt that the online sewing community is a generous and supportive place about which many of us feel passionate - your many eloquent comments are testament to this. It seems that this has made it difficult for any constructive criticism about products and activities (if that's the right phrase) to be voiced. Is there a way that this can change without the nature of the community being altered negatively? Many of us seem to go by the rule "If you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all" - is that the best way?

Caroline's comment that the sewing community is a uniquely positive and non-judgemental place created by and for women, really resonated with me. There seem to be few 'safe' online places for women and we are very lucky to have the online sewing community. Yes it does have its flaws - sometimes it can be/appear cliquey, but part of this reason is that real life friendships have formed from a common passion and these are played out semi-publically. There are many ways in which participating in the community has enriched the lives of participants; learning and improving skills, increasing confidence, making friends.

In the comments that were left, there is a very strong sense of people getting fed up of seeing the same type of posts on numerous bloggers, without begrudging the occasional freebie or blog network post. We are in a period of intense blogging activity and it will be interesting to see what will endure in the long term. Have we reached blog hop saturation point? How many more bloggers-turned-pattern designers will there be? How many more book deals and hobby-to-professional bloggers?

From a purely selfish point of view it was lovely to receive comments about my own blog and I feel really encouraged about posting more charity shop finds and some outfit posts too. The Pattern Monday posts were also mentioned so I promise fans of this series that I will revisit my pattern collection to dig out a few gems as I know I have a few I never got around to blogging. The problem with this series is that I now have a large collection of seriously ugly knitting patterns. When I die, if someone I don't know looks through my collection they will just think I had terrible, terrible taste.

Mmmmmmmmmmm....beige.....

As mentioned, I'm starting a new series of posts about the fabric and yarn shops in Glasgow. I hope this will be of interest to locals and visitors to the city and I will add them to a page on the homepage of the blog. There are some great shops and as their websites have varying amount of information I thought it would be useful to put together something which covers them as equally as possible.

I've chosen 10 shops and considered various ways to space the posts - 2 blocks of 5 days? A couple per week? In the end I decided to go with one post weekly for 10 weeks, so as not to overwhelm or bore those who will never visit Glasgow - though maybe you will after you read about where to buy fabric?

The posts will appear weekly on a Sunday from the 28th September. I was going to give you a list of the shops in advance but instead I'm going to surprise you each week with the shop I've chosen. They range in location from the city centre to the west end and southside.

I should add that all opinions are my own and I have not been paid to write any posts. Depending on the shop I have sometimes spoken with the owner or shop staff and sometimes not. Some shops are small so it's impossible (not to mention rude) to take photos without doing so!

I hope you enjoy the posts, and I will be still posting the usual work in progress/finished items/deeply philosophical musings alongside this series.

K x

30 comments:

  1. Your summary of the comments is spot on! I followed the previous post with interest because it's something I've been thinking about recently too. I think there is room for constructive criticism in the blog world, and I dislike that we're all "too nice" to say anything about it. I'd very much like my makes to be critiqued, because how else am I going to learn when something is off? Although that's never going to happen until more people follow my blog heh.

    I also like the idea of doing outfit posts - I do think I'll start doing that soon!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Laura, glad you enjoyed the post and comments

      Delete
  2. Looking forward to all your plans :) My grandad was Scottish born in Glasgow but I have never explored it properly. I will look forward to seeing the fabric hotspots, for when I can get to visit!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great, you should definitely visit and check out the shopping :)

      Delete
  3. I find both this and your last post really interesting. I am relatively new to blogging about sewing (as in I have only really sew blogged since Earlier this year), but feel I have stepped into an already established community. Is it right to criticise how someone presents their blog or the direction they take? I don't know. I can't judge the bigger blogs fairly, as I have not been reading them for long enough, but it is easy to avoid reading posts and there are always new bloggers coming on the scene with fresh ideas, which makes it exciting. On a personal level I think it's great that so many people are able to create and market a product through this medium, but that could be because I'm one of those people who is about to release a pattern. I was nervous about this and when I asked a friend her thoughts, she told me that without new Indie companies popping up we are just creating a new big 4! Maybe not quite, but it is good to encourage new ideas. I guess it's just a case of balancing your blog and your product, so that it still remains true to why you originally started writing. Have I got the point of this discussion? I'm not sure, but what I'm trying to say is that we can pick and choose what we read, just as a blogger can pick and choose what they write. Vote with your mouse as to whether or not the content is worth reading!

    As for your suggestion of outfit posts, I think that's a great idea! I like to see people's treasure (even if it does result in charity shop envy) and find it inspiring to see how different people put outfits together. Still can't stop thinking about your clogs by the way! Maybe sometimes share a dodgy knitting pattern just for fun! X

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Marilla,

      What you say about stepping into an established community really rings true for me too - I started blogging just over 2 years ago but it's taken a long time to feel like I wasn't trying to but into the "in-crowd". I think my main issue with sewing blogging at the mo is that it can feel a bit cliquey - but then it all depends on who you read, and as you say there are always new blogs to discover!

      Also, I just randomly stumbled on your NYLon post as saw that you're from Reading - me too! I haven't been there for a very long time sadly as all of my family have moved to various other places, but I still have a soft spot for it :-)

      Delete
    2. Thanks for your comment Marilla, you're right that we can pick and choose and there is so much choice now.

      Delete
  4. It's been fascinating, thank you for beginning such an interesting debate. Looking forward to the shop reviews, and yay! for ugly knitting patterns!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hope you will enjoy the reviews - I'll try and dig out some patterns too

      Delete
  5. urgh, I'm really annoyed - I wrote a long comment on your last post, only to find that my mobile device has ignored/eaten it and now I can't remember what I said. I think it has been a very interesting discussion and I am glad that some of the gripes I was beginning to have with some blogs have resonated with other people too - mostly because I now realise that I'm not being a grumpy old bag! I do resent being constantly marketed to at the moment, but as someone else said, we can alway vote with our mouse and not read them any more. I like your blog because you are still you and whilst I don't knit, I am still amused but the slightly odd patterns you manage to unearth!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Argh, that's so annoying about your post. My phone is rubbish for commenting with, I always have problems. I'm glad you felt your own concerns were reflected in the comments, they were fascinating to read.

      Delete
  6. I forgot about the ugly knitting pics. They always generate a smile or a laugh. Even though I live in the States your blog posts about places in Scotland have made me an armchair traveler to your neck of the woods. I am a curious person by nature and this feeds my curiosity. About a month before your post I had weeded through Bloglovin and eliminated all but three sewing blogs that I had followed. Your blog was one of the three I kept. Why? Because you keep it real. There is nothing pretentious in your blogs.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you - I feel honoured. Glad you enjoy the blog .

      Delete
  7. I came across that photo in my album the other day. I got giddy. I had such a blast meeting everyone that day. No matter how cold it was :)

    I love your ugly knitting posts. It's nice to start my day with a laugh. And I'm all for outfit posts! I myself am having a hard time thinking about what to write because my projects take so long in between the other. Having to shape my new blog identity has been hard. Sometimes I just want to write about what I'm doing because I know family reads my blog and they would enjoy it. But then I wonder how much is too much to share. Ugh. Such a balancing act!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Edinburgh meet up was lovely wasn't it? It's hard to work out what to blog about sometimes, I found my lfe has changed too and I want my blog to reflect my concerns but also still be like my own space that I can do what I want with it.

      Delete
  8. Oh the Beige Fluffy Hair Ladies, they ought to be villains on Dr Who!! Terrifying! hehe. Great work, Kerry, I read all the comments on the previous post with great interest, felt that the discussion was indeed a refreshing change from both the happy happy usual stuff and GOM, which I refuse to read or participate in, but get told about occasionally. Intelligent, honest ideas and opinions. I rarely read the posts of certain bloggers, choosing instead to skip over them in my blogrolls. I ought to delete them entirely but it helps to know what's happening in an overview as these things come up across a range of blogs.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, I'm really glad you enjoyed reading the comments, so much food for thought there wasn't there?

      Delete
  9. Oh wow, that pattern is... special!

    Unfortunately, as far as blog hops go, publishers these days want authors with big social media followings, who can get their friends to promote their books, that way it saves them having to do it. In some cases the publisher controls the hop regarding when and over what period, in others it's up to the author if they want to make it less frequent and spread out. One poor friend was in utter despair at having to completely organise her own promotion of her second book, because she'd got a new job since then (following a divorce and accompanied lifestyle change) and was struggling to find the time to sort it all out, not to mention the fact that publishers didn't even honour the prize winners for the 2 giveaways until prompted 3 times.

    I guess what I'm saying is that as long as big bloggers are getting book deals, there will be multiplying hops.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What a rubbish situation for your friend, you'd like to think your publisher would be a bit more supportive! I can see that blog hops are a great way for publishers to get the word out without spending the cash so the hops won't be going away any time soon. I don't mind the odd one and have taken part in them too, but sometimes you look at the list of blogs involved and think 'Great, I'll be seeing this book everywhere for the next couple of weeks'.

      Delete
  10. I'm glad you're going to post about Glasgow fabric and yarn shops. I think it's always nice to see how it is elsewhere, rather like I adore going to grocery stores in other countries. Fascinating.

    Blog hops, pattern rolls and the like are indeed saturated. Once you seen a pattern you've seen it. Luckily it's easy to mark a post as read on my reader and move on to something more interesting.

    Also, I adore your charity shop finds, so stick those in there without looking back!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh now you've given me an idea, I could more from fabric shop reviews to supermarket reviews :-)

      Delete
  11. That pattern. Scarily similar to something my mum actually knitted. Ok ( deep breath) true confession. She used some kind of tweed yarn and hers was beige and mine ( yes!! Mother and daughter !!) was blue. Batwing. A half floppy roll neck that flaps down like a triangle. It had off centre line of cabling as well. I would have been in my early teens. Gosh that feels better to have got that off my chest. Glad you'll bring back pattern Monday! And your charity shop finds!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sounds beautiful! I've got to ask - any photos? :-)

      Delete
  12. This has been a very interesting thread Kerry. Having taken an extended break from blogging, I have only recently started reading again and I've noticed the change in the posts that are popping up in my reader. I was considering whether to remove the ones that no longer interest me ie. the promotional ones or just mark them as read and move on hoping that they might have something I consider worthwhile reading in the future. I prefer to read blogs that inspire me to continue sewing/crafting and trying new things. I've always enjoyed reading your blog as you keep it interesting, giving a little insight into who you are at the same time. Keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Shelly - interesting that you've noticed a change after having a break. But as you and others have said it's our choice to decide not to read them. Glad you enjoy the blog.

      Delete
  13. My comment got eaten too! I went back to see if you'd replied and it's no where to be seen. I did end up reading every single comment and have to say I left very dejected.

    I thought I was playing the game in the most sensible way I could. I've always believed that any reviews I do of products, even if supplied for free, are honest. And that I only accept things that I'd be willing to buy myself and make things I would have made regardless. But perhaps none of that matters from the outside. Maybe I seem like a massive sellout, promoting companies and products.

    It would certainly account for the fact that several of my blogging friends no longer comment on my site. We still meet up and have a wonderful time but perhaps they don't actually enjoy my blog anymore. I can't quite bring myself to ask if they're actually even reading anymore?!

    Perhaps I'm reading into things too much, but a blog is as much about your readers as it is for yourself. There should be a balance and maybe I've lost it. Though you obviously can't please everyone.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Amy - sorry about your comment disappearing, very weird. You certainly do sound dejected by the comments. Regarding making blog comments generally, I have noticed that I normally get so few compared to what I used to, and I think this is reflected generally across sewing blogs. But I still get readers so I know from my blog stats people are reading still. Personally I mostly read blogs on my phone and commenting on that is a nightmare so if I really want to make a comment I have to remember to go back to the blog again when I'm at the computer. But I also interact more on Twitter now so I think the comment culture is generally changing and it's not a reflection of who is reading and enjoying your blog.
      All of the comments have made me think more about my own blog and since I've started the discussion I feel I need to be extra careful if I accept anything for review as maybe people will think I'm a terrible sell out. But I've accepted free things in the past when they were relevant to me and the blog and I would keep doing this from time to time if offered. I certainly do turn down offers too. I don't think you need to feel too disheartened, we're at an interesting time for blogs just now and your personality and interests come across well in your own blog and at the end of the day, that's what people enjoy.

      Delete
  14. Thanks for your lovely reply! I totally agree with you about the changing ways people comment. I've seen major spikes in my twitter and instagram followers / likes / comments recently. It's so quick to comment I definitely love using those apps too. I also have a major problem with blog commenting and phone signal. I'm actually typing this reply for a second time! Everyone can have valid reasons for not commenting so I try to not get too disheartened by that. I think it's the not knowing who's unhappy with the free products I'm getting that troubles me. It's such an unknown. And I'm a worrier in general! It's funny, I totally understand in work and in life you can't get on with or please everyone but for some reason I still want to with my blog. I can't seem to let that go.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Interesting..I found this blog elsewhere after a comment about your post on sewing blogs...and I'll stay because I'm off to Glasgow for a day or two in December and I suspect I will be coming back with an extra bag full of fabric after reading your shop reviews :D
    But I agree with a lot of what's been said. I rarely update my blog (I'm moving house soon and I'm about to pack away my sewing machine for 3 months), and the blog links I have in the sidebar really don't reflect the actual blogs I read regularly - they are blogs I started to read when I first got nto sewing, mostly based on reviews of patterns I'd bought on Patternreview!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Oh..and that knitting pattern..is epic. Beige acrylic and hairspray - static electricity dream!

    I have a book of 50s knitting patterns, and it includes knitted knickers, and a knitted shirt and tie for a little boy...amongst other 'delightful' garments...

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for reading and commenting - I love to hear what you have to say